A Taste of Balsamic Vinegar

A Taste of Balsamic Vinegar

Wine tasting? That is so yesterday, haven’t you heard? Balsamic vinegar tasting is all the rage!

On Saturday afternoon, Maxence and I attended such a tasting, organized by the Bastille Slow Food convivium. It was held at Sur Les Quais, a spice and oil store in the covered area of the Marché d’Aligre. I’ve always been very fond of the taste of balsamic vinegar, but the wildly varying prices of what you find in stores are confusing, so I was delighted for the chance to learn more.

Paul Vautrin, the store owner, started out by telling us about balsamic vinegar and its characteristics. It is produced from the must of very mature Trebbiano grapes and aged in a series of barrels of different sizes and woods. He explained how the producer transfers a fraction of the vinegar from the younger barrels into the older barrels every year, which is why the age of a bottle of vinegar is only an average, being a mix of older and younger vinegars. The types of wood the barrels are made in, the quality of the grapes, the initial concentration, and the producer’s savoir-faire all come into play to make (or break) the quality of a balsamic vinegar.

Naturally, industrial companies started making balsamic vinegar too, aging it in steel tanks, cutting it with water and coloring it with brown sugar or caramel. In response, the original small producers have created a consortium and a D.O.C. (Denominazione di Origine Controllata, if you must know) to protect the century-old tradition : only vinegar produced in a small region around the town of Modena can claim to be the traditional balsamic vinegar of Modena, their products are made following strict rules and are bottled and boxed in a specific way.

The real thing is very pricy (50 euros for 10 cl), but the taste is so intense and concentrated that just a few drops are sufficient. Of course the scope is pretty wide between the real unique nectar and its crappy over-industrial version, so a good dealer should be able to recommend a producer who may not belong to the consortium but still follows the rules, hence producing a quality product at a somewhat lower price.

The actual tasting began with a small glass of saba, the must (unfermented juice) that is used to make balsamic vinegar. Incredibly sweet and sirupy, with a strong grape taste, saba can be diluted in water or wine to make an excellent drink, or poured on ice-cream or fruit for dessert.

After this little starter, we conducted a cool blind test : each participant got four little numbered glasses of vinegar, otherwise unmarked, and a grade sheet to take notes on the visual, olfactory and taste characteristics of each. That was a lot of fun, as we took on our most earnest air to sniff and sip and observe and gurgle. One of them was really really bad, with a terrible vinegar smell that unclogged your sinuses and a sour taste to match. Two were fruity to the smell and very pleasant to the taste, but not sour enough, and would have overpowered a savory dish. And the final one was just the right mix of sweet and sour, with a subtle but distinctive taste, fragrant and tart enough not to go unnoticed, without jumping at your throat. Much to our glee, this turned out to be the connoisseur’s opinion.

We also got a taste of real traditional vinegar, which was indeed even better balanced than the blind test winner, and we tried white balsamic vinegar. Its taste was pretty similar to dark balsamic vinegar, but my tastebuds may have been past their peak of alertness by then.

We were then served some nibbles that the staff at Sur Les Quais had kindly prepared : a tomato and star anise cocktail, toasts of tapenade, quartered cherry tomatoes, slices of avocado, slivers of parmesan, strawberries and ice-cream, all prepared with the star of the show. My vote goes for the parmesan seasoned with a little balsamic vinegar, a simple and delicious amuse-bouche.

This was all very friendly, fun and instructive, and we bought a small bottle of balsamic vinegar (the one we liked best in the blind test) to take home. And a little coriander anchovy tapenade, because that was just irresistible.

Sur Les Quais
Marché Beauveau
(Marché couvert d’Aligre)
Place d’Aligre
75012 Paris
01 43 43 21 09

  • This sounds absolutely wonderful, Clotilde! I’ve never had the opportunity to go to a tasting (of anything) – very jealous here. I’ll have to go and check whether my balsamic is indeed the real thing…

  • We once did a whole balsamic vinegar dinner. Every dish had some form of balsamic in it. Our guests were really surprised by dessert, though: vanilla ice cream with traditional balsamic vinegar drizzled on top.

  • sylvie

    Fabuleux cette séance de tastevin-aigre ! Quand je pense que j’en ai acheté l’autre jour de la marque Champion à 2,59 euros le 1/2 litre !

  • I went to a birthday party this weekend where the honoree had made her own red velvet cake with balsamic vinegar instead of red wine vinegar. You couldn’t taste the balsamic, but it made the normally subdued cocoa flavor shine through.

  • Rebecca

    I have just one question: what WAS the vinegar that you liked best? (I’ll have to look out for such a tasting – there is even more range in quality in balsamic vinegar than in wine, I think!)

  • boreal

    I would KILL to attend a balsamic tasting. The company has stopped importing my favorite kind about two years ago, and its just been a wasteland since. Its amazing the *variety* which is out there in forms of taste. Its gotten so fricking expensive trying to find something new I enjoy as much as my former favorite.

    Ok, maybe I wouldn’t kill, but I sure would love to attend a tasting here. So who was your favorite? Did the group as a whole prefer one? Not that I could find it here, but curious. Also glad you went over the history and legal status now, its all very interesting isn’t it?!

    Bread recipe on the way.

  • Angela – I love the idea of tastings, and it’s actually something fun to organize for yourself and some friends, with a few bottles of wine, a few different kinds of chocolate, anything, really!

    Derrick – That must have been lovely, and who can resist a themed dinner anyway? :)

    Maman – Ce type de vinaigre balsamique est probablement tout à fait bon, on peut juste contester l’appellation!

    Barrett – I had no idea there was vinegar in a red velvet cake! It’s interesting that the balsamic vinegar complemented the chocolate well…

    Rebecca – Well, you know what? The bottle has a very simple label with “vinaigre balsamique” on it, so I don’t even know! I’ll try to find out…

    Boreal – The whole group did agree on which was the best one, but some did prefer the fruitier ones to drink as is! :)

  • Medo

    today i have bought the “red grape balsamic Vinegar”, but my question is how can i serve it , what shall i delute or mix it with ? just a cold water or with a grape juce? and what in the ingredients , how many spones for each glass, i want it to be veeery adjusted ,
    thank you

  • Speaking of Balsamic Vinegar tastings, there is a store that just recently opened up near me about 2 years ago in Columbia Missouri that does in fact offer tastings of balsamic vinegars. It is a gourmet food store called World Harvest Foods and they are a store that carries what they consider to be the best of the best. They will give you tastings of any balsamic vinegars off their shelves (the best part is it’s for free), anywhere from $15 a bottle all the way up to the Aceto Balsamico Tradizionale Extra Vecchio (25-Year Extra Aged Traditional) valued at $165! If you ever happen to be in or around Columbia, Missouri, you should visit them and just ask to taste their vingers. Every time we go there, we fill our selves up as we taste all kinds of new and unusual (and some old things that are the best of the kinds we used to always use) cheeses, olive oils, vinegars, honey, etc. Check them out on the internet at http://www.worldsfoods.com

Get the newsletter

Receive FREE email updates with all the latest recipes, plus exclusive inspiration and Paris tips. You can also choose to be notified when a new post is published.

View the latest edition of the newsletter.